the prince
Before Charles, King of France, came down into Italy, the
country was controlled by the pope, the Venetians, the King
of Naples, the Duke of Milan and the Florentines. Necessarily,
these powerful states had two main concerns: to keep foreign
armies out of Italy and to prevent each other from grabbing
more territory. The pope and the Venetians were the most
eager expansionists. The only way to hold back the Venetians
was for all the other states to band together, as they did in
the defence of Ferrara; to frustrate the pope, on the other
hand, they relied on the Roman barons. Since these barons
were divided into two factions, the Orsinis and the Colonnas,
they always had something to fight about, and with their
swords drawn under the pope’s nose they kept him weak and
indecisive. And though from time to time you might get a
really determined pope, like Sixtus, all the same he was never
quite cunning enough or lucky enough to solve the problem.
The reason was that papacies tended to be short-lived. In the
ten years, on average, that a pope was in power he might just
manage to beat down one of the two factions; but if, for
example, one pope had almost finished off the Colonnas,
the next would be hostile to the Orsinis and so resurrect the
Colonnas, but without quite having the time to see off the
Orsinis. This is why the Italian states did not rate the pope’s
temporal power very highly.
Then came Alexander VI, who more than any other pope
in history showed what could be done with finance and force
of arms. Using Valentino Borgia and taking advantage of the
intrusions of the French, he made all the gains I mentioned in
my discussion of Duke Valentino. And though Alexander’s
aim was to make his son great, not the Church, all the same
his achievements enhanced the power of the Church, which,
after his and then Valentino’s death, inherited his conquests.
So on his election Pope Julius took over a Church that now
possessed the whole of Romagna and was all the more power-
ful because Alexander had quashed the Roman barons and